Materials Transparency in Use: Addressing Gaps
In the last five years, and with several Materials Petal equivalency/full pursuits underway in our project portfolio, we’ve observed a range of a 30% decrease to a 53% increase across various material certifications. The variance in participation applies to both well-represented and emerging participating divisions alike – hello, Construction Specifications Institute – which is both exciting and surprising. The observed decrease is evidence of something many of our design team members do not anticipate when starting their project’s vetting; decertification and/or allowing certifications to lapse after their expiration date. Decertification has become a major barrier for more design teams acknowledging materials achievements in the way we currently vet aesthetics, cost, and durability.
One of the biggest hurdles firms – especially firms of scale – struggle to mount is how to get ahead of changing information in an industry where design and installation can often take years.
Firms need tools with open APIs across all certifying bodies to navigate this complexity. Firms also need designers who understand and appreciate we’re still in the sweat equity phase of verified materials transparency. These two items could yield increased consistency in green building certification and reviewer protocols, among other pros. Perhaps continuing to celebrate how far the industry has come is one path forward to continue the momentum. Addressing observed gaps is also another.
Here are a few areas where our industry could be solicitous:
- Adhesives and sealants: We need both volatile organic compound emissions and content confirmation, especially when it comes to structural joints or epoxy anchors. We typically must vet two or three manufacturers before we find a solution with confirmed use on a similar project and satisfactory confirmation – keep in mind certifications are left to expire, so we have to exercise the process anew for each client. Similarly, adhesives or sealants that are part of a warrantied assembly where only the tangible finish layer has achieved a Red List Free Declare label, or something similar, has become a pattern. We often get excited about a product and then pivot away from specifying because parts of the compatible assembly don’t have the same level of transparency.
- Domestically sourced tile: There are a few exceptions but certified product from small- to mid-sized manufacturers is hard-to-find. This difference in resources, especially in the case of this product type, causes designers to weigh trade-offs between verified achievement versus celebrating local materials.
- Gypsum: For wall assemblies with the weight of today’s emphasis on optimized acoustics, in tandem with materials achievement, we are decently limited as prioritization in performance criteria is continuously revisited.
- Ancillary furniture and lighting: There are many aspects in these product categories where the sustainability story is still catching up to where the flooring industry was 10 years ago. On a recent project where RoHS – aka Restriction of Hazardous Substances – verification was required for lighting, of the 74 manufacturers engaged, 24 had not heard of this standard driving optimization in lighting.
As a multi-disciplinary, integrated design firm, there are a multitude of challenges and opportunities to sole-sourced materials for a project. Among them, the speed of delivering modern technologies in the world we find ourselves in since early 2020 simply outpaces the speed of certification. Solving the gaps noted above takes persistence, and clients who trust their design teams to push on their behalf. We do need to celebrate those partnerships and accomplishments. Today, we have availability in steel studs, fully compatible resilient flooring assemblies, demountable wall systems, acoustic panels, textiles, raised access flooring, high performance coatings, and more ceiling tile options now available for peers and other building sectors to specify. Note, these are products both tangible and intangible.
Wellness and sustainability can still be communicated to building users even if it is not directly visible.
Some product optimizations take truly less than 10 minutes. Vetting for energy code or confirmed durability might take longer than ingredients, carbon, or emissions verification, in some instances. But there is still not a holistic, automated easy button tying together all vetting factors designers must hurdle. While we work together to solve for the easy button, calling out these gaps might inspire more across our industry to meet the demand in anticipation of the ask, should it not have landed already.
Sustainability Action Plan
A Lasting Housing Impact: Gen-Z Redefines Multifamily Living
A new generation has moved into the multifamily and student housing space, and brought unique preferences for how to live.
Designing for a Disaster: Resiliency in a Changing Climate
A case study in disaster preparedness: explore how planning ahead can mitigate some of the devastating effects of environmental disaster.
Presenting on Equity at SCUP Pacific 2023 Regional Conference
Join Principal Leigh Anne Jones and Senior Associate and Architect Catherine Meng for a conversation on designing equitable facilities for students.
DLR Group to Present at SCUP Pacific 2023 Regional Conference
Principal Jaclynn Eckhardt will be presenting a session on strategies for actionable stewardship based on her master planning experience.
A Deep Dive on Data Center Growth and Development
Join Principal Jonathan Mesik, PE, as he dives into how providers are meeting data center growth demands with speed, scale, and sustainability in mind.
Mass Timber Innovation: The Hospitality Prototype
The world has reached a crucial tipping point around carbon emissions. Could timber construction be the answer for the hospitality industry?
Designing Equitable Public Safety Facilities
The design of public safety facilities impacts recruitment, retention, and building community.
DLR Group to Present Augmented Reality Talk at USITT
Learn ways to heighten your design story through new and emerging technologies in this presentation from Principal Raymond Kent, AIA, LEED AP BD+C.
Watch: Delivering on Design Vision and Building Performance
When the Portland Building needed comprehensive repairs, the design team's solution respectfully preserves this architectural icon.
DLR Group Presents on Workplace Design and Wellness
Learn how to integrate and communicate the value of workplace sustainability goals and wellness strategies to leadership and employees.